The Surly fats bike battle! Nicely which bike is finest? We’re going to evaluate these two iconic fats tire bikes facet by facet and see what the distinction is between every. In relation to worth the Wednesday is $450 cheaper at $1550 when the Ice Cream Truck is $2,000. However what actually is the distinction and which one is finest for you and your using objectives?
The Wednesday is classed by Surly as a “highly versatile fat tire trail bike.” It’s a nice throughout fats bike, with the soul of a path bike and the thoughts of a touring bike. Whereas the Ice Cream Truck however is taken into account as a “trail ready, maximum tire clearance fat bike”. It’s the bike you select when you haven’t any concept what the path goes to by means of your approach!
Reading: Surly wednesday vs ice cream truck
Primarily in a sentence in order for you a really extensive fats bike tire and plan to trip essentially the most hardcore terrains the Ice Cream Truck is right. The place in case you are simply stepping into fats bikes and want one thing to begin out with the Wednesday is perhaps a better option.
Surly WednesdaySurly Ice Cream TruckMSRP$1,550$2,000CategoryTrail (fatbike)Fatbike (Path)FrameSteelSteelForkSteelSteelWheel Size26″26″Wheel MaterialAluminumAluminumBrake TypeHydraulic DiscHydraulic DiscGroupsetNX Eagle, SX EagleSLXDrivetrain1 x 121 × 12Max Tire Clearance26 x 4.6”26” x 5” Weight35 lbs or 15.9 kg35 lbs or 15.9 kgStack/Attain Ratio1.351.4Chainstay Size435 mm440 mm Path81 mm88 mm
Nevertheless it goes far more deeper than that, I nonetheless must get into the small print and clarify why!
The Surly Wednesday appears to be that bike you get if in case you have a 50/50 steadiness using trails and do off-road touring. It’s the good bike in Surly’s lineup to keep up this sort of using. In case you are searching for a fats bike however not thought of about getting the fattest tires available on the market then the Wednesday is an possibility price contemplating. Because it has a max tire clearance for 26 x 4.6” tires.
The Surly Wednesday is taken into account a 26″ metal body inflexible path bike with higher mid-range elements and hydraulic disc brakes. It comes with a 1 x 12 NX Eagle, SX Eagle groupset which has a SRAM NX Eagle DUB crank and SRAM PG-1210 Eagle 11-50t cassette. Not too certain what number of tooth the crank has however I imagine it’s 32T or 30T (not 100% certain.)
Read more: Planting in ice cream cones
You get the Surly Nate 26 x 3.8˝, 60tpi, tubeless prepared tires on the Surly My Different Brother Darryl, 80mm w/speedholes rims. In relation to handlebars you get a 31.8mm with 11 diploma. As each bike get hydraulic brakes the Wedneday comes with the Tektro HD-M275 / M276 brakes with 160mm rotors.
What’s fascinating is each these bikes (from what I might inform from analysis) have the quick chainstay and longer chainstay changeability possibility. So for the Wednesday which means that the Full-forward, quick chainstay place has room for 26 x 3.8˝ tires on 80mm rims; and the full-rearward, longer chainstay place can match as much as 26 x 4.6˝ tires on an 80mm rim.
What’s the weight of the Surly Wednesday? From my analysis about the identical because the ICT at 35 lbs or 15.9 kg. As you may see within the desk beneath there may be the breakdown for body, fork and frameset collectively, with out full construct.
The Wednesday additionally comes with fashionable mountain requirements, like stealth dropper submit routing, 44mm headtube, suspension correction, entrance and rear thru-axles. Then lastly first rate quantity of braze-ons, entrance and rear racks, a number of units of three-pack mounts, fenders.
Surly Ice Cream Truck
Okay now let’s check out the Ice Cream Truck. So whats completely different? From technical singletrack to sandy or snowy circumstances, this bike can do all of it. From Surly’s gross sales web page; “we designed a monolith of a trail bike that doesn’t give two shits about what’s in front of it.” Okay in that case, Ice Cream Truck, you go the job!
If you wish to most clearance for a fats bike. That is the one, boasting a clearance for a full 26” x 5” tire on 100mm rims! Described as a 26″ metal body inflexible fats bike with higher mid-range elements and hydraulic disc brakes. With a 1 x 12 SLX groupset, you get a Race Face AEffect w/ DM30t crank and Shimano SLX CS-M7100 10-51t cassette, which is 1 smaller tooth on the small ring then the Wednesday.
Read more: Thai tea ice cream recipe
What about weight? This rig is available in at round 35 lbs or 15.9 kg. Which is anticipated for a metal fats bike. However because of the geometry this bike managers to preform relatively nimble for its weight!
The Ice Cream Truck comes with the Surly Bud & Lou, 4.8″, 120tpi tires on the identical Surly My Different Brother Darryl, 80mm w/speedholes rims. And the Salsa Rustler handlebars that are completely different to the Wednesday. In order for you a extra in-depth take a look at every bikes elements in contrast facet by facet see the desk beneath.
Specs Aspect by Aspect
WednesdayICTBodySurly Wednesday, 100% Surly 4130 Chromoly metal. Surly Wednesday, 100% Surly 4130 Chromoly metal. ED coated. Double-butted major triangle. TIG-weldedSurly Ice Cream Truck, 100% Surly 4130 Chromoly metal. Surly Ice Cream Truck, 100% Surly 4130 Chromoly metal. ED coated. Triple-butted major triangle. TIG-weldedForkSurly Wednesday, Tapered straight blade 4130 Chromoly. Surly Wednesday, Tapered straight blade 4130 Chromoly. 468mm axle to crown, 47mm offset. 51mm I.S. entrance customary disc mount, 150mm x 15mm thru-axle dropouts (axle included), 100mm suspension fork appropriateSurly Ice Cream Truck, 1-1/8″ straight steerer with tapered straight blade. Surly Ice Cream Truck, 1-1/8″ straight steerer with tapered straight blade, 4130 Chromoly. 483mm axle to crown, 47mm offset. 51mm IS entrance customary disc mount. 150mm x 15mm through axle dropouts (axle included).Backside BracketSRAM DUBRace Face 100mmHeadsetCane Creek 10Cane Creek 40, ZS44/EC44Stem4 bolt 31.8mm4-bolt 31.8mmHandlebar31.8mm 11 degreeSalsa Rustler w/o logoSaddleWTB VoltWTB Volt 142Seatpost30.92-bolt 30.9mm
WednesdayICTRear DerailleurSRAM SX EagleShimano SLX RD-M7100 12 SpeedCrankSRAM NX Eagle DUBRace Face AEffect w/ DM30t N/W ringShiftersSRAM SX EagleShimano SLX SL-M7100-RCassetteSRAM PG-1210 Eagle 11-50tShimano SLX CS-M7100 10-51t 12 SpeedChainSRAM SX Eagle x12Shimano SLX CN-M7100 12 SpeedBrakesTektro HD-M275 / M276, 160mm rotors entrance & rearTektro Gemini HD-M520Brake LeversTektro Gemini HD-M520
WednesdayICTRimsSurly My Different Brother Darryl, 80mm w/speedholesSurly My Different Brother Darryl, 80mm w/speedholes Tubeless ReadyFront Hub150 x 15mm thru-axle, 32h, blackNovatec 150x15mm 32hRear Hub177 x 12mm thru-axle, 32h, blackNovatec 197x12mm 32h w/ Shimano Microspline freehubTiresSurly Nate 26 x 3.8˝, 60tpi, tubeless preparedSurly Bud & Lou, 4.8″, 120tpi
Geometry – Straggler Vs Midnight Particular
Geometry can play a giant half within the distinction of how I bike rides and feels. It’s positively one thing to think about when shopping for a motorbike. However all of the measurements beneath are in mm and are for each medium sized bikes.
BikeWednesdayICTStack587598Attain436427Stack/Attain Ratio1.351.4High Tube Size610610Seat Tube Size416419Seat Tube Angle73.573Head Tube Size110105Head Tube Angle6968BB Drop5560BB Top288283Entrance Heart693698Chainstay Size435440Wheelbase11221131Rake4747Path8188Standover Top774803
From trying on the numbers above, there are very comparable geometries. The path of each is on the bigger finish which is anticipated for fats bikes. However the ICT has a 7mm longer path which in idea would make it extra predictable to deal with particularly when there’s a lengthy on the entrance of the bike.
Chainstay lengths are shut with a 5mm distinction. Each sitting in that chill vary. Nevertheless the ICT has an extended wheelbase by 9 mm making it extra steady for these bikepacking adventures.
The Wednesday has a a lot decrease standover peak at 774 mm in comparison with the ICT’s 803 mm. The Ice Cream Truck offers a barely extra upright using place. With the stack/attain ratio of 1.4 in comparison with the Wednesday’s 1.35.
General they each seem to be an ideal alternative. I’m personally contemplating stepping into fats biking. And any of those bikes would just do wonderful for somebody like me. Nevertheless, once I give it some thought, for journey biking and using extra superior fats bike terrain, the Ice Cream Truck is the most effective guess. However if you wish to lower your expenses and aren’t think about about gnarly adventures throughout dessert sand, the Wednesday is totally succesful.
Read more: Ice cream places in gatlinburg